Kulturkompasset | critics of culture events

EL AMOR BRUJO – GOYESCAS in Florence


EL AMOR BRUJO – GOYESCAS

Opera di Firenze, Italy, 2016 Febrary 2nd

Review by Fabio Bardelli, Photos Opera di Firenze

FIRENZE/ITALY: A Spanish setting diptych was presented at Opera di Firenze, a performance including the 1915 ballet El Amor Brujo by Manuel de Falla and the rarely performed opera Goyescas by Enrique Granados, whose premiere took place in New York in 1916.

Goyescas, ensemble, Foto Opera di Firenze MMF

Goyescas, ensemble, Foto Opera di Firenze MMF

Granados derived the work from his own homonymous piano suite with the support of a particularly frail, thin and almost embarassing libretto which stages the classic plot of jealousy, with the inevitable final duel. A disappointing plot that does not allow the composer to go over a certain vagueness in musical writing, and which doesn’t seem to affect too much the Florentine audience.

Goyescas, ensemble

Goyescas, ensemble

Conductor Guillermo García Calvo shows solid craft and a certain refinement in concertation and in following the voices, among them emerges soprano Giuseppina Piunti as Rosario, even with some efforts in the upper register. Good enough Andeka Gorrotxategi as Fernando, less well Anna Maria Chiuri as Pepa but especially disappointing was baritone César San Martin as Paquiro. Paul Antognetti completed the vocal cast in fairly good way.

The Orchestra and the Choir trained by Lorenzo Fratini were really in good shape.

This staging of Goyescas can be defined normally didactic, stage director was Andrea De Rosa also author of rather superfuous scenes, while the refined appropriate costumes were by Alessandro Ciammarughi. In the beautiful costumes and in the staging there are some visual suggestions from Francisco Goya‘s works, but this thing seems not to go beyond a rather sterile quotation without reaching an autonomous meaning. 

Goyescas, Punti, Gorrotxategi

Goyescas, Punti, Gorrotxategi

Maria Toledo in AMOR BRUJO, photo Opera di Firenze MMF

Maria Toledo in AMOR BRUJO, photo Opera di Firenze MMF

 In the first part of the evening the presence of Maria Toledo wasn’t enough to hold the attention of the audience who, considering her disappointing rendering both as “cantaora” and as “bailaora”, surely more enjoyed the musical part (El amor brujo by Manuel de Falla) conducted with a certain property by Guillermo García Calvo.

Mrs Toledo shows a voice not lyrically set and therefore needing a microphone, which incidentally was not even well balanced with the orchestra. The artist doesn’t seem able to go much over a mid-level performance without great personal conviction and even less involvement of the audience.
Overall it was a rather modest and a bit boring Spanish diptych in which we rarely “breathed” Spanish atmosphere, a medium and not very inspiring evening for the disappointed scarce Florentine audience, almost a tangible sign of the difficulties facing the Opera di Firenze. The success was little more than of courtesy.

EL AMOR BRUJO
Musica di Manuel de Falla
Coreografia di Pastora Imperio
Direttore, Guillermo García Calvo
Cantaora and bailaora, Maria Toledo

Orchestra del Maggio Musicale Fiorentino

GOYESCAS (Los majos enamorados)

Musica di Enrique Granados

Direttore, Guillermo García Calvo
Regia e scene, Andrea De Rosa
Costumi, Alessandro Ciammarughi
Luci, Pasquale Mari
Maestro del Coro, Lorenzo Fratini

Orchestra e Coro del Maggio Musicale Fiorentino

Rosario, Giuseppina Piunti
Fernando, Andeka Gorrotxategi
Paquiro, César San Martin
Pepa, Anna Maria Chiuri
Una voce, Paolo Antognetti

 

Tagged as: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,